Packet Beat on my Alfresco - Insane numbers

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Highlighted
Member II

Packet Beat on my Alfresco - Insane numbers

I have enabled Packet Beat on my Alfresco and my Confluence Server

Its 2 public sites with very little activity, the Alfresco is only for me.

Even though, the Alfresco generates 1,5 Millions SQL "statements" over 24 hours.... that is insane..

Why...

3 Replies
Highlighted
Master

Re: Packet Beat on my Alfresco - Insane numbers

I don't consider the raw number that insane really, unless you are able to drill down the number to individual types of queries that can be correlated with feature sets that should not be used. Alfresco includes a variety of background processes that are scheduled to run in regular intervals, e.g. SOLR index tracking which gets triggered ever 15 seconds. Due to the normalisation of data in the database, various interactions require multiple SQL statements to be run in short succession.

The graph you included appears to be very consistent with regards to the number of statements per minute. Is there a way to get an overview over an entire 24 hour period so you can check if there is a specific time when a background process may be triggered that skews the overall number? With 1.5 million statements, you have an average of ~17 per second, which may sound high for a under-utilised system unless you can account for any spikes / background processes.

Highlighted
Member II

Re: Packet Beat on my Alfresco - Insane numbers

Well, everybody has a right to a opinion, but its insane, I will stille claim that. A system not used for 24 hours at all (as in: No content change), performs 1,5 mill SQL statements and indexes every 15 seconds ... is that full indexing each time.

I have a Confluence running beside the Alfresco, it like 700 SQL statements over 24 hours - and only indexing when content is updated. As an Operations man looking into I/O and CPU/Memory - the Alfresco is a "waste" of ressources.

Heres 7 days of packet log - 66 millions ... for a system virtually not used...

Highlighted
Master

Re: Packet Beat on my Alfresco - Insane numbers

So those packets all relate to either the general overhead of JDBC connection pool management (obtaining a connection, validating it, commit/rollback handling) or mostly index tracking. The numbers for rollback and select ... from alf_transaction are unnaturally high. Instead of ~8 million they should be at around ~80.000 with the default configuration (actually, there shouldn't be any rollback during idle). The high numbers for the other aspects related to connection management are likely just a result of the rollback and retry functionality within Alfresco.

By activating debug logging for org.alfresco.repo.transaction.RetryingTransactionHelper you'll likely see in the application log what (temporary) errors may cause Alfresco to trigger a rollback + retry. You should find the output in the alfresco.log file.

My statement regarding "sanity" was in the context of the Alfresco application / architecture, not in comparison with other applications. Just as Confluence, Alfresco was once architected to only index when data actually changes, which provided a significantly smaller idle footprint but did not scale well enough for larger system installations. Alfresco was never designed / intended / optimised for a single-person/mostly-idle use case, rather it focuses on hundreds and thousands of users and efficiently dealing with consistent load as a core application in an organisation.